When a UK-based electricity producer was experiencing frequent breakdowns due to bearing failures in two industrial fan units, the plant requested the services of NSK to propose and implement a suitable solution. After performing an application review as part of NSK´s AIP (Added Value Programme), a change of bearing and fixing arrangement led to significant cost savings. An NSK application review attributed the root cause of industrial fan unit failure to incorrect bearing arrangement
The two direct-drive overhung fans, which are supported by spherical roller bearings in plummer blocks, operate 24/7. As primary total air fans, their role is to feed air to the boiler at a rate of 8 m3/second with an output pressure of 13 kPa. However, the bearings in each unit were failing every three months on average, a situation that would take three engineers 10 hours to remedy each time, incurring high costs per breakdown. The long time and high cost of replacement was largely due to the size of the task. Each fan is around 3.5 m in diameter and attached to the end of a 2 m long, 135 mm diameter shaft. Shaft rotation is 1487 rpm, powered by a directly coupled 350 kW electric motor. ”Condition monitoring was being performed by the plant on both bearing units for each fan,” explains NSK Sales Engineer Dennis Briggs-Price. “Temperature would be monitored continuously by a magnetic probe, with weekly vibration checks performed on each bearing, measuring velocity in a radial position [vertical]. Normal condition readings would be around 70°C, with a velocity of 5 mm/s. Every time these values were significantly exceeded, the bearings would be replaced by the plant as a precautionary measure as imminent failure was perceived. Typical values achieved before replacement would be 90-100°C and 20-33 mm/s velocity. Indeed, a recent bearing failure on one unit broke the steel frame/mounting brackets, with excessive temperatures and vibration figures recorded. In the past, the plant had even tried balancing the fans using a third-party resource, but the bearing failures continued.” NSK´s comprehensive application review included a failed bearing examination from the drive and non-drive end bearings. A number of issues, including fretting corrosion, were noted to the external diameter of the outer ring. It was also clear that both bearings exhibited a raceway which had supported an axial load; evident from a wider and more pronounced running band. This is unusual as the fan configuration had a fixed and free-end arrangement – to allow for shaft expansion from operating temperatures – thus the free end should only support a radial load. As the free end bearing at the energy plant exhibited axial loading, NSK was able to attribute the root cause of the ongoing failures to incorrect bearing arrangement. High-capacity Spherical Roller Bearings within SNN Plummer Blocks were therefore recommended, along with correcting the fixing arrangement. NSK´s Spherical Roller Bearings use state-of-the-art materials that make them suitable for high speeds and loads. Offering special ring tolerances to withstand vibration, shock loads and misalignment, the bearings are heat stabilised up to 200°C. Furthermore, high-capacity Spherical Roller Bearings were the preferred choice as the internal design is more reliable for direct-coupled overhung industrial fan units, thanks largely to inner ring ribs that provide better roller guidance. ”A trial was conducted with our engineering team overseeing the installation and implementation of our recommendations,” explains Mr Briggs-Price. “The result was zero bearing failures over a 12-month period. Furthermore, our solution offered increased productivity with reduced maintenance and downtime costs, with four times greater bearing lifetime.” As can be seen in this example, using the wrong bearings or fitting them incorrectly can reduce the output of machines or industrial units, and even cause a whole plant to grind to a halt. NSK´s AIP is designed to make operations and maintenance processes more efficient and more profitable by saving money at each value-added step. Experienced NSK specialists use a tried and tested method to develop the ideal solution for each specific application, working with the customer and taking every requirement detail into account. At the UK energy plant, the AIP process encompassed services from initial survey and product selection, through to customer training and final inspection. The results speak for themselves. Due to the new solution, savings of €134,040 are being achieved annually based on reductions in bearing costs, fitting costs and downtime costs.
Spherical Roller Bearings from NSK – which were chosen as the internal design is more reliable for direct coupled overhung industrial fan units – use state-of-the-art material technology that makes them suitable for high speeds and loads.
Direct drive absolute value unit
Machinery in a variety of industrial sectors has benefited from the properties, safety standards, compactness and precision of the positioning units driven by KOLLMORGEN linear motors.
Today, the well-known Mondial linear motor modules, long-established on the market, are more efficient and have higher quality standards, smaller dimensions, and an excellent price-quality ratio thanks to the compactness and safety of KOLLMORGEN products.
Mondial Spa is one of the foremost companies in the power transmission sector. For more than half a century, it has represented leading foreign companies, designing and producing a wide range of specialist products which can meet the most varied demands of many different industrial sectors. It is a parent company of the group of businesses specializing in the design and manufacture of specialist bearings for a number of different industrial applications. Boasting a design department, unusual feature for a distribution company, the Mondial Group works very closely with its clients to meet their needs, optimizing costs and benefits.
Mondial needed to update and expand its range of modules driven by linear motors and upgrade the product design and performance in order to be able to offer customers a new and improved range of components in line with trends in the market as well as its own quality standards. The improved performance of the product has to be allied with the affordability of the proposed solutions; this was to be the key to success.
The Milan-based company began their search for a well-known partner in the market with which to operate in partnership. A meeting with KOLLMORGEN confirmed their interest in collaborating with a leading company capable of producing complete solutions. The result was a winning combination: both players immediately saw opportunities to increase their presence and competitive strength in the Italian market where the first applications combining the Mondial linear units with KOLLMORGEN linear motors were introduced at the start of 2017.
“The start of this partnership has been very exciting for us” explained Angelo Trombetta, Direct Drives and Mechanical Transmission Manager for Kollmorgen Italia, who has been with the project from the outset. “We have worked well with the Mondial team, mutual sharing has been useful and rewarding for all: this project has been a start, we want to tackle new challenges, continuing to provide the added value which is our hallmark”.
Complete linear movements with a high level of performance
Mondial uses KOLLMORGEN motors is its linear movement systems, which make up one of the most extensive ranges of direct drive linear modules on the Italian market. The benefits of direct drives are clear: very high performance, OEE (overall equipment efficiency) performance, no deterioration in performance over time, providing a transmission with maximum efficiency. The direct drive of a linear motor under load also means that mechanical transmission components, recirculating ball screws, gears, belts, and other components can be done away with, eliminating mechanical play, increasing rigidity and therefore productivity.
The linear units produced can be used in a wide range of machinery in applications such as printing, packaging, presses, plastic deformation, machine tools, handling, laser cutting, measurement, inspection, milling, assembly, textiles, simulators, and many more.
Transport and positioning unit MLM7 N
High levels of dynamic performance, considerable load capacity, and precision are the distinguishing features of the new MLM7 N series from Mondial. It is a complete feed and positioning unit, vital for linear movement in precision applications. The base component is made from high-strength extruded aluminium, which can be used as a free-standing element, the profile of which has been designed to suit different types of linear motors. It also provides high translation forces, whilst always ensuring fluidity of movement. The delivery programme, updated by Mondial, is structured in order to satisfy any application requirements in terms of speed, precision of positioning, load capacity, etc.
With regard to protection systems, the basic version has been designed with uncovered guide rails and protected recirculating ball slides with standard friction seals. The version with a linear motor has a stainless-steel plate to cover the motor. If the application requires, the MLM7 module can also be fitted with a PVC protective bellows. On request, Mondial can design and produce special protection systems to suit specific safety requirements or working environments. Maintenance is reduced to a minimum with this new range: the different versions incorporate a grease distribution system for all the moving components; the version with a linear motor uses lubricators integrated into the recirculating ball slides. The Mondial linear motor systems can also be fitted with inductive, magnetic, and optic linear encoders.
A direct drive linear motor is, in fact, a rotary engine laid flat and driven directly under load.
With no mechanical transmission components, the design offers an exceptional level of performance, very high rigidity, dynamic speed, and acceleration, a high level of positioning precision, compact dimensions, low cogging, maintenance-free running, and quiet operation as well as a high degree of precision.
Advantages of the ICH linear motors
- Maintenance free, increased precision and bandwidth
- Uniform speed profile and reduced noise
- Transmission of forces without mechanical components such as couplings, toothed belts, etc.
- No gear reducers, screws, or lubrication
- Increased reliability of the application
- Vast selection of motor sizes with differing power ranges for universal use in all linear drives
- Increase in performance of the entire system
- Compact drive solution with reduced height
- Simple and more compact design of the machine
- Increased bandwidth and response speed compared with ball screw or gear-wheel drives.
- Reduced noise, fewer components and lower overall operating costs
Where the robots come from?
Collaborative robots were a big feature of the Hannover Messe trade show again in 2018. Small, intelligent, sensitive, and self-learning: The ways in which robots can be used are increasing all the time. And the level of acceptance is also rising – not least thanks to attractive prices and short ROI times. Off-the-shelf handling solutions are in demand and Yuanda Robotics has a range of market-ready robot systems. For its drive technology, this young company from Hannover depends on the robotics expertise of KOLLMORGEN.
You know about our horses, now find out where the power comes from! With slogans like this, Lower Saxony is confidently advertising its own innovative strength – something which is most apparent in its robotics expertise. The region’s claims to market leadership were once again made clear at the Hannover Messe 2018 – not least in the shape of start-up company Yuanda Robotics. Founded just over one year ago, the company exhibited a number of robots for performing various load-carrying tasks. Inside, they are powered by specially customized servo motors from KOLLMORGEN’s KBM range. What is remarkable about these is that the powerful synchronous machines are frameless and can be embedded in the construction of the robot straight from the kit. The main advantages of this are that it saves space, and heat can be extracted far more efficiently.
Dr. Jens Kotlarski likes to lead his new robots by the hand. “In the same way as I would show things to my child, I show them to the machine,” says the managing director of Yuanda Robotics GmbH – a successful spin-off set up by three scientists from the Leibniz University in Hannover with funding from the Shenyang Yuanda Aluminium Industry Group in China. The company from Hannover is aiming to successfully bring different types, such as the L.3, M.3 and M.6 versions which, they exhibited, to market by the end of the year. The robots are designed to act as automated handling assistants for manual assembly lines in industry. “That’s why our robots have a similar reach to the human arm,” explains Kotlarski. “Humans are not really able to move loads of 5 kg or more ergonomically for long periods – especially if the parts also have to be lifted from low down to high up”.
For example, one specific area of use for the new robots from Hannover would be the loading of machines. Insert the component, press the button, wait, remove the component, and put it in a box – all day long. These are monotonous tasks that are avoidable. Kotlarski believes that people can be used far more cost-effectively in other ways. Before setting up Yuanda Robotics, he worked as a group leader at the Institute of Mechatronic Systems at Leibniz University in Hannover. The first “Made in Hannover” robots are principally designed to serve as production assistants for continuous operation. Among other things, using them in this way raises the question of how the heat from the drive technology can be most effectively dissipated.
High power density
This is where the frameless structure of the KOLLMORGEN KBM motors can improve heat extraction simply by convection across the robot’s joints. The effect of these excellent thermal properties is that the KBM motors can reach peak performance without derating. “The high power and performance density were important reasons why we used these motors,” explains co-founder Matthias Dagen. Small motors with a high output are essential if the arms and the joints are to be made as compact as possible. “The thinner and more lightweight the design, the heavier the loads that the robot will later be able to carry,” explains Dagen. Overall, it improves inertia behaviour and the ratio between the robot’s own weight and the weight it can carry.
Nevertheless, the requirement for lightweight construction has its limitations because a certain surface area and mass are needed in order to dissipate the heat effectively. But this is where the KBM motor assemblies from KOLLMORGEN prove to have particularly robust thermal properties. The stator winding has been defined by the specialists in servo drive technology and motion control as having continuous capability at an internal winding temperature of up to 155°C. Aspects such as this were crucial criteria when the motors from the KBM range were being designed and dimensioned. There was close cooperation on the engineering between Yuanda Robotics and KOLLMORGEN – mainly in the person of KOLLMORGEN project manager Markus Grohnert. “Having a personal contact was also important to us when we were choosing the most suitable drive manufacturer,” emphasizes Matthias Dagen. In addition to the strict performance criteria, delivery times for the components were another key factor for the young start-up company. “We need to be able to rely on short timeframes, if we are aiming to bring new products to market quickly,” says Dr. Jens Kotlarski.
Quick delivery for quick start-ups
The short delivery times for the frameless motors in the KBM series are mainly possible because each bespoke drive system is the result of a clever combination of standard components. Refinements can be made, for example, to the rotor hub dimensions, stack length, diameter, assembly jigs, windings, connection type, and much more. Part of the work of the engineering project at Yuanda Robotics consisted of Markus Grohnert making sure that the direct drive was perfectly matched to the intended robot gear system.
When it comes to control units, by the way, despite the ready availability of products that have been tried and tested in industry, Yuanda Robotics relies on in-house development. “We are aiming for a highly integrated solution that can’t be achieved with standard control units – in terms of function or price,” explains Matthias Dagen. The main reason for this is the special algorithms which are supplied to the control unit. Dr. Jens Kotlarski: “To do that, we have to go deep into the control technology and we want to eliminate all the superfluous functions that standard control units inevitably bring with them.” The two men are happy that they are able to bring to market a solution that has been deliberately reduced to the essentials. Both are in agreement: “KOLLMORGEN’s experience with frameless direct drive motors made them perfect partners for us in this kind of robotics work, including on the electromechanics.”
The bottom line
With their new series of robots, the company from Hannover is marketing a solution that provides everything that is needed to automate assembly and handling tasks quickly and reliably. The overall package is nicely rounded off by the integrated camera technology in the robot. This enables the robot to identify the products it needs to pick up by itself. For the visualization, the company has taken advantage of the potential of so-called augmented reality. This means that, when the parameters for new tasks are being set, the movements of the robot in the workspace can be exactly simulated – and then they can be sent out to start production. Helping people to understand these complex systems is one of the main objectives for Yuanda Robotics, in the hope of further increasing the acceptance of robots.
Neugart: Gearboxes for automation and robotics
Mechanical and industrial engineers in this industry sector must maintain an incredibly difficult balancing act: delivering cost-effective products without sacrificing quality and durability. Neugart understands the difficulty of striking this balance. We understand that highly automated plants often run around the clock over the course of the whole year. Since our founding, we have been developing and producing planetary gearboxes tailored to suit these needs, constantly striving to improve our products in cooperation with our customers.
Our gearboxes strive to fulfill the most diverse requirements, depending on the type of gearbox application a client intends to use. Highly dynamic, linear handling applications demand robust, high-performance components. Thanks to the low weights of the drive components, multiple axis systems achieve a positive regulating effect and, as a result, offer more-efficient throughput times. Pick-and-place systems, on the other hand, demand high repeatability and a corresponding system rigidity that promotes fast and precise placing.
Neugart planetary gearboxes can be customized according to your requirements. They operate reliably and precisely, aiming to meet our customers’ requirements, regardless of what they may be.
Cost effective gearbox solutions: Neugart planetary gearboxes use modular designs for a wide range of flexible configurations and customizations. Because of this, our customers benefit from a cost-effective acquisition price – without sacrifice to quality.
Reliable gearboxes with long lifespans: Our planetary gearboxes do not need lubricant change. Our unique design facilitates a lifetime-lubricated gearbox that performs its tasks reliably.
Smart technology for all product aspects: It’s not always simple to find the perfect gearbox for specific applications. Gearbox applications are complex and many factors will come into play during the decision process. Neugart software tools are easy to navigate and help to simplify potential questions or difficulties.
Worldwide availability: There is virtually no country in the world that does not currently use a Neugart gearbox. We have built a network of experienced sales engineers around the world so that you will always have somebody there for you — no matter your need, no matter where you are.
“We have relied on Neugart and its gearboxes for years because of the excellent advice regarding application, the high product quality and the optimally coordinated product range. In the case of our servo-clinch machine, we could not have used a better planetary gearbox.”
B.Eng. (DH) Florian Unger | Head of Development | Eckold GmbH & Co. KG
Case study: Clinching — the joining technology of the future
Florian Unger is the Head of Development at Eckold GmbH & Co. KG in St. Andreasberg, located in the Harz region of Germany. He has relied on Neugart gearbox technology for years. Mr. Unger explains, “The entire unit is easy to adjust with this gearbox manufacturer. The diverse product range provides the correct gearbox for every possible application. We have found the perfect gearbox for us here – compact, powerful, maintenance-free and at a fair price.
About the company
Eckold GmbH & Co KG is a medium-sized company founded over 80 years ago. As a manufacturer of specialized machines, the Eckhold & Co focuses specifically on joining and forming technology. They concentrate primarily on clinching, stamping and semi-tubular punch riveting technology. Company owner Gerd-Jürgen Eckold brought clinching technology onto the national market in the 1980s. Today, clinching has become indispensable in the automobile industry, household appliances and air conditioning and ventilation technology, not to mention spot welding and riveting technology. This is one of very few technological solutions available to use when different materials such as sheets of steel and aluminum need to be joined together without ancillary parts.
Eckold started retrofitting and enhancing its pneumo-hydraulic clinching machines on electro-mechanical systems years ago. While both technologies remain available, there is also a clear market trend towards electro-mechanical systems. For components with different individual or total thicknesses, it is almost always necessary to adjust the base thickness in order to positively influence the undercut and stem thickness formation. A complicated matrix change is needed when using pneumo-hydraulic systems because of the fixed cylinder stroke.
With an electro-mechanical system, due to the variability of the drive stroke, the user is typically no longer reliant on a matrix change, which is more flexibly positioned in the electro-mechanical system. Other advantages clearly lie in automation and the implemented continuous quality monitoring, which can be controlled in the software program.
We see examples of this in automotive applications, where clinching pliers are mounted as a complete unit on an articulated robot (known also as joint-arm robots) and operate autonomously in production lines. Creating compact units are of the utmost importance, as compact clinching unit are absolutely necessary in order to reach areas of the automobile body that are difficult to access. With the parallel design of the gearbox and the planetary roller screw, Eckold’s machines were extremely compact right from the start. A servomotor drives the planetary gearbox directly. This is connected to the planetary roller screw through the use of a belt and generates an axial movement with a high degree of pressing force. The radial force resulting from the pre-tensioning of the belt must be absorbed by the bearing technology of the planetary gearbox that is used. The requirement of the OEM’s for more compact units and the need to reduce cycle times prompted Eckold to look for alternatives on the market.
A new gearbox undergoes a strict testing procedure at Eckold during qualification. Each gearbox unit is tested in-house and must perform 10 million strokes, in order to simulate real-world use. If the gearbox passes this test, the clinching units are delivered to the OEM’s for field-testing. The devices are then returned to the factory and analyzed in detail every 2.5 million strokes. Only the units that pass this process with 100% effectiveness have a chance of making the short list.
As Eckold set out to find a new gearbox, numerous units underwent their rigorous tests and trials. Finally, after Eckold completed their search, a Neugart gearbox was chosen. The arguments for using this gearbox are noteworthy, as it offers countless benefits in comparison to previously used gearbox technology. The Neugart gearbox has extremely high efficiency of around 98%. It is about 10mm shorter, lighter and reaches a performance data that is 5 to 10% higher than previous models. This gives clinching machines two advantages: the weight reduction increases the controllability of the articulated robot and therefore also reduces the process times. Additionally, our smart unit is even more compact. With the application of a Neugart gearbox, the Eckold clinching machine is unrivaled on the market.
It was just as important to the Eckold engineers for the gearbox not to have to be re-greased during the machine cycle, even though the components were operated on a robot arm in any spatial coordinates. The customer therefore receives a drive train which can generate an axial clinching force of up to 100 kN. In addition to the technical advantages, Neugart gearboxes are a more cost-effective solution in comparison to previous gearbox models.
Proof of DIN ISO 9001 certification and listing with well-known OEM’s was the prerequisite for being validated as a supplier to Eckold.
Customers have reported no problems or failures since the implementation of the Neugart gearbox in the clinching systems. Eckold uses the outstanding application knowledge of Neugart contacts in order to detect and remedy irregularities in the overall system. Last but not least, this is supported by the Neugart NCP layout software which is available free of charge to Neugart customers. Each new application at Eckold is designed with this program and subsequently used as part of the technical documentation. Developers then use the Neugart Tec Data Finder to automatically download their specific gearbox as a configured CAD model.
Even in the reforming and punching technology area, hydraulic and pneumo-hydraulic drives are being replaced with electromechanical drive trains. Eckold supports this market shift with their latest machine types. One challenge for the future will be the option of joining a wide range of new materials using clinching elements. Maintaining machinery with long service lives will continue to be an important criterion for gearbox selection within the industry. All this presents new challenges for the components that are used. Because of the positive experience the company has had, Eckold is highly motivated to strengthen its collaboration with Neugart.
What is clinching?
Clinching, also known as press-joining, is an innovative and proven technique for joining metal sheets and profiles. The permanent joints are exclusively created on the basis of local cold reforming, without additional or ancillary joining components. The main feature of this joining method is that the form-fitting joint is created from the material of the sheets that are being connected.
Because of this, the parts that being joined together can have either the same or different sheet thicknesses and even be made from the same or different materials.
Industrial Hardware and Machine Parts5 ay ago
Rexnord adds to its Autogard Torque Limiters with the XG Series
Motors7 ay ago
Get a first-class ticket to productivity
Industrial Hardware and Machine Parts5 ay ago
ABB and Formula E partner to write the future of e-mobility
Industrial Hardware and Machine Parts1 sene ago
The necessity of bolted flange connection training
Motors1 sene ago
ZF Technology on the Winners’ Podium of the Dakar Rally 2017
Motors1 sene ago
New generation of hollow shaft motors
Industrial Hardware and Machine Parts1 sene ago
Custom hobbing tool enables 45-degree angles
Motors1 sene ago
Interroll introduces a new generation of drum motors